Tuesday, March 31, 2020

Yoko's Tribute for Cynthia

Photographed by Bob Gruen

"I’m very saddened by Cynthia’s death. She was a great person and a wonderful mother to Julian. She had such a strong zest for life and I felt proud how we two women stood firm in the Beatles family. Please join me in sending love and support to Julian at this very sad time. Love,"
Yoko Ono, 2015


A short statement wasn't enough for Yoko; so she wrote a longer statement that she submitted to Rolling Stone magazine.


"Cynthia was a Hoylake girl, which meant she was from a district of Liverpool a notch above where the members of the Beatles all came from. John met her in the Art School, and was immediately taken by this straight-A student, who also had a warm mischievous smile. A professor who was always in a tweed jacket with a pipe in his mouth, as John put it, gave a 'friendly attention' to her which irritated John to no end.
Indeed, one could not help noticing Cynthia’s zest for life, and the beam of sunshine coming out of her eyes. She already embodied love and peace in her quiet manner. The 'boys' as they were called forever, behaved differently when she was in the room. I wonder how much her presence encouraged the group to go all the way to the top.
Since my son Sean is also a mom-and-son boy, my pain of Cynthia’s sudden departure is very deep. It was a big shock to everyone. You never know what deal life cuts for us.
It seems like only yesterday, when we four met, Cynthia, Julian, Sean and me. I thought she was looking like a young girl with strong love and pride for her son, Julian, who managed to have his photo exhibition in New York City, known for being a difficult place for artists to be successful. We were a family.
Being a single parent of a strong and intelligent boy is never easy. Cynthia and I understood each other in that way, wishing well for our sons and their future. It’s hard to imagine what this totally unexpected turn means to her only child. I don’t want to go there.
Please join me in giving love and support to Julian at this very trying time for him. Thank you."
Yoko Ono, 2015
Both are nice statements from a widow for an ex-wife. My wondering curiosity peaked when she mentioned that John got irritated by a professor taking an interest in Cynthia. Never heard of that one, although it's more amusing that John even mentioned that to Yoko. Same with him being immediately smitten with Cynthia; I can't imagine John mentioning that to Yoko. Guess he did! I wonder what else he told Yoko about Cynthia that we don't know about? I know that a certain amount of people criticized Yoko for these tributes as she was the catalyst of their divorce. However, it was a no-win situation. If Yoko hadn't done these and be silent, Yoko would surely get criticized for being quiet; damned if she did, damned if she didn't. I may not be Yoko's biggest fan, but I can say that these were nice and I believe they were genuine from the heart. I do think that the news shattered Yoko more than we all know. Whatever happened in the past, you can't argue that Yoko and Cynthia had two things in common: both loved John and both had his sons. I think in some ways, especially from their exchange at Mimi's funeral in 1991 that Yoko looked up to Cynthia's parenting and used the inspiration for raising Sean. Kyoko was still a child when Yoko last saw her in 1972ish until the 1990s, so the teenage years of raising a minor was very new for her. I have noticed in the years since Cynthia's death that Yoko has been more warm with Julian. I don't know if they've seen each other recently after Cynthia's death - certainly must have communicated. Yoko included Julian in the recent Imagine book and documentary Above Us, Only Sky. Yoko also recently included Julian on John's death anniversary of missing John on December 8th. To be on the record, Yoko did include Julian in her letter used against her husband's parole hearing some years back, before Cynthia's death. For his part, Julian hasn't complained about Yoko other than praising her. So,who knows?


Both photographs of Yoko and Cynthia at Julian's photography exhibition at Morrison Hotel Gallery in New York City on September 16, 2010. The second photo with Sean and Julian.

Watering Cynthia's Hat




Photographed by Robert Whitaker

Monday, March 30, 2020

Volume III: Life with Aunt Mimi

"She was friendly but cool. Regal, almost."
Cynthia

"I think that I was probably the successor to Aunt Mimi in John's life."
Yoko Ono

A postcard (front and back) sent by Aunt Mimi Stanley Smith from her holiday in Florence in 1966 to John and Cynthia at their Kenwood home in Weybridge, Surrey. 
Source: The Beatles Memorabilia: The Julian Lennon Collection 2010


I don't know how often Mimi visited John while he was living in Weybridge. I know she definitely did. She was certainly there in the Summer of 1965 when John brought her a new house in Bournemouth (there's a post already done). Once the money started to roll in, John gave weekly allowances to his mother-in-law Lillian Powell and his Aunt Mimi; somehow Mimi found out and was furious as she didn't feel that Lillian should get such a thing but John just shrugged it off. It was his money, after all. Then came 1968 and John's domestic life changed.
John introduced Yoko to his Aunt Mimi around June of 1968 when it was clear that he and Cynthia were over. He brought along Yoko to the home he bought his Aunt in Bournemouth.


"He had rung to say he was bringing someone down. He came in all bright and breezy -typical John- and she followed behind. I took one look at Yoko and though, 'My God, what is that?' Well, I didn't like the look of her right from the start. She had long black hair, all over the place, and she was small- she looked just like a dwarf to me. I told John what I felt while she was outside, looking across the bay. I said to him, 'Who's the poisoned dwarf, John?'"
Mimi Smith

"I thought she was beautiful, so tall and slim, with beautiful skin and bone structure. When John went to the bathroom and left us alone together, Mimi told me how she's brought him up to be very good mannered, and always stand up when a woman came into the room."
Yoko Ono


During the visit, Mimi talked about the Duke of Windsor being at one time popular but lost it all when he left the royalty behind when he married Wallis Simpson, comparing John and Yoko to them.

"John just laughed. He laughed it off, but he knew I didn't like her and he knew I was a good judge of character. I couldn't see what he saw in her and I thought it was wrong and nothing good would come to it."
Mimi Smith


After Cynthia's divorce from John, she and Julian didn't see Mimi until 1972 at Harrie's funeral. At one point, Mimi approached Cynthia to scold her about the divorce: Cynthia should've fought harder for John and their marriage from Yoko. Mimi felt that John and Yoko were making fools of themselves but Cynthia was powerless- what John wanted to do, he does it. Cynthia promised Mimi that she and Julian will visit her… I don't know if that happened or not. I believe that they definitely saw each other again at Mater's funeral in 1976. 
Yoko and Sean outside of Mendips in Liverpool where John grew up in January of 1984


When Sean was born, the first call John made was to Mimi. During her last conversations with John, he promised his Aunt that he'll see her when he planned to visit England as well as the rest of the family to meet his son Sean. He hadn't really seen Mimi since he left England for good in 1971. They last spoke on December 6, 1980. Unfortunately, John was murdered. Mimi originally heard from Neil Aspinwall who called her but he was crying too much to barely speak. I did hear that Yoko called Mimi to confirm the news, including to Julian and Paul McCartney.
Mimi didn't meet Sean until 1984, the only time. Sean had been begging both parents to go to England- John was gamed. Yoko finally took him to England to show him John's home country. Mimi adored Sean.
As for Julian, it's hard to really say but there was a time in the 1980s that Julian briefly lived with Mimi in Bournemouth (it must've been after 1983 when Mimi said that Julian doesn't keep in touch) I don't recall where I read that nor do I know if it's true or not. After Mimi discovered that John never transferred her name as the owner of her home and realized that Yoko was now her "landlord", Mimi was not happy about that but also feared that Yoko would send someone over to check on her so she swapped the photos of Julian to Sean's. Despite that, I do believe that Mimi was more closer to Julian than to Sean in a sense... But, I also believe that Mimi and Julian weren't close at the same time… do you get what I am trying to say? I suppose what I am saying is that there was more accessible contact between Mimi and Julian than she had with Sean. Mimi was there when Julian was born, she literally watched him grow up while Sean was born and grew up without her there on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean. As she did with John on his budding music career, Mimi did the same thing with Julian's music career in a disapproving way. If alive today, no doubt that Mimi would be the same with Sean's musical career.


"It's difficult- I don't remember too much about Mimi. I remember her house, the outside of it. She used to have on the driveway there was a tarmac with white pits in it, I recall that and it was by the sea, I think. I remember Dad used to have, like, a stretch Mercedes, white one, which we used to go to visit her in. But apart from that, I couldn't tell you much more. He used to talk about her a lot, not to me in general but he used to talk about her. If I was in the room, I'll be listening. No [contact], because I don't know, I didn't really, I don't know, but I guess I didn't really feel a part of that. I was just dragging along going to be seeing this relation to Dad so to speak. I don't remember there being a closeness. I mean, there might have been there but I don't recall."
Julian

"I have to admit Yoko was a good wife and mother and, thank goodness, I told John so long before. Sean is a darling, he's the living image of John. He has his mannerisms and his sense of adventure. We are very good friends. He tells me what he's been up to and I tell him all about his dad. He's very interested and can't discover enough. When he's twenty-five he'll be a very rich man, but for now he needs a good education. Yoko is a sensible girl and is seeing to that." 
Mimi Smith, 1983

"I think Julian ought to get a real job. I've heard him sing and it's not my cup of tea. Julian doesn't keep in touch, not that it worries me too much." 
Mimi Smith, 1983

"Sean is like John in every way- looks and manner- and he has got John's sense of humour. His speech, his self-confidence- and he's quite the entertainer! As long as he keeps away from music, he will be alright" 
Mimi Smith, 1984

“Sean got on so well with Mimi, it was great. It was beautiful to meet her again. I had a lovely day - it was really beautiful. I’m glad that I came back here, and I’m glad I showed Liverpool to Sean. We came to Liverpool for Sean - it’s his heritage. We’ve had a wonderful day.“
Yoko Ono, 1984


By 1991, Mimi was very ill with heart problems and had a nurse with her. Her niece Julia notified Cynthia that Mimi's time was winding down so Cynthia reached out to Mimi for peace and closure. From what I understand, it went cordially well. 

"I do not recall Mimi mentioning Sean except in passing. As I said before, she was not fond of Yoko. She did not like being beholden to her for her. Yoko owned her house and paid for all Mimi's needs. Mimi was a very strong person and liked to be in charge. Actually, she always referred to her as that 'Yoko Poko' person. However, Mimi's bark was always worse than her bite and I have a feeling that she may not have truly had as much animosity as she pretended."
Lynn Varcoe, Mimi's nurse, 2011

"I do not remember Cynthia or Julian getting in touch with Mimi during this period. Mimi always spoke well of Cynthia."
Lynn Varcoe,  2011


Mary Elizabeth Stanley Smith died on December 6, 1991. Ironically, the 11th anniversary of her last phone conversation with John; two days before his death anniversary. Her last words were "Hello John". 
Mimi's funeral was held at Poole Crematorium on December 12, 1991. Cynthia attended, accompanied by Julia. Yoko and Sean also attended. As did Julia and John's sister Jacqui. Julian didn't go, he was elsewhere. Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr, and George Harrison sent floral wreaths. Mimi was cremated.


Cynthia attending Mimi's funeral on December 12, 1991


"I went with Cynthia to Mimi’s funeral. When I realized that Mimi was terminally ill, I had tracked Cynthia down to where she was then living, on the Isle of Man. I thought she had a right to know and I gave her Mimi’s phone number, and Cynthia did speak to Mimi, shortly before she died. We took the train to London and stayed in Julian’s flat overnight, leaving early the next morning for the journey to Poole. Most of the family were already in the house by the time we got there, but the door was opened by complete strangers, who told us where to put our coats and where the bathroom was. I was astounded. Who were these people?"
Julia Baird

"Yoko and Sean were at the funeral and so was Cynthia. I remember Cynthia being very upset and crying throughout… After the funeral, we all went to lunch at the Harbour Lights Hotel in Sandbanks. Yoko was very gracious and thanked all the people that helped care for Mimi. She thanked me for being there when Mimi died. Sean was also very polite and attentive to his mother."
Lynn Varcoe, 2011

Yoko and Sean at Mimi's funeral on December 12, 1991


According to Cynthia's book, John, Sean had a lovely time at the funeral… not exactly a thing to say for a funeral, but in that defense, Sean was meeting a lot of relatives he'd never met- probably the only time for some. Yoko tried to mingle but eventually gave up and smoked her long cigarettes, only one maybe two puffs before smashing it out before starting up a new cigarette. Yoko did turn to Cynthia for parenting advice on raising a teenage boy (Sean was 16 at the time).
It was during the funeral that Cynthia used the opportunity on behalf of Julia and Jacqui to confront Yoko about a house issue… but that will be saved for a post on its own.

Friday, March 20, 2020

Big Hands, Little Hands





Yoko, Julian, and John watching the Rolling Stones' special Rock n Roll Circus on December 11, 1968. I love how John's hands are holding Julian's. Also pictured: Brian Jones, Roger Daltrey, and Eric Clapton's shoulder.

Wednesday, March 18, 2020

In His Own Write

Cynthia and John arriving at the Dorchester Hotel for the Foyle's Literary Guild in John's honor on April 23, 1964

I don't know when John got a book deal for his drawings and writings of poetry & short stories. It must have been sometime in late 1963, or January of 1964 due to its release in April, including an appearance in The Beatles movie A Hard Day's Night. I mean, 4 months to get everything ready? Wow! I think there's a quote by George Harrison saying they were doing one week's work packed into one day… No kidding! Then again, there weren't any distractions as there are now (prime example: cell phone). Although, granted John must have had quite a number of his stuff already done that inspired a book deal. Cynthia remembered him working in a rushed panic in between filming and recording A Hard Day's Night trying to reach the deadline in time. The cover photograph was taken in the kitchen of Emperor's Gate by neighbor and photographer Robert Freeman. In His Own Write was published on March 23, 1964.
On April 22, 1964, John filmed scenes for A Hard Day's Night, running around on the field and, later, being chased by the police (John did a lot of running that day). That night, John and Cynthia went to the Ad Lib Club, partying until early hours of the morning. They returned home and woke up a very few short hours later, hungover and bloodshot eyes. They fumbled to get ready to go to Dorchester Hotel for the Foyle's Literary Guild luncheon, held in John's honor on April 23, 1964. Both had forgotten their glasses and had to bravely encounter press and literary folks. As mentioned in the A Hard Day's Night post, John missed filming the remaining moments of the Beatles' running in the field scenes. John's absence in that part is very noticeable but I honestly love to think that at that moment John was with his wife. I pretend that John was doing something no good while the other three were on camera. 
It was one of those posh/rich parties that would've been fit for the Queen or some kind of country leader. Brian Epstein accompanied them, mixing elbows with his type of crowd. Among the guests were Earl of Arran Arthur Gore, Marty Wilde, Victor Spinetti, Wilfred Brambell, Arthur Askey, Harry Secombe, Millicent Martin, Joan Littlewood, Helen Shapiro, Yehudi Menuhin, Mary Quant, Sir Alan Herbert, Lionel Bart, John Bloom, Alma Cogan, Cicely Courtneidge, Peter Daubeny, Carl Giles, Frank Norman, Victor Silvester, Colin Wilson, and a whole lot more. The event was hosted by Osbert Lancaster. It started at 12:45 PM until 1 PM with lunch… I don't know what was on the menu but from the pictures I've seen, for sure bread rolls were served. There was wine and tea. 
At some point during the meal, the room got quiet. Cynthia didn't know what was going on and asked what was happening. She was told that John had to make a speech. Cynthia freaked, she knew John wasn't prepared. Also, for some strange reason, she and John were sitting apart. Three people (men) were sitting between them. There had been different accounts of what John said in his speech but thankfully it was recorded on film… regardless of what he said, it was very short and quick. No more than 10 words. Honestly, I don't think John was a speech type. Paul McCartney is a speech type. Paul would have easily taken that kind of event with such ease and professionalism, mingle and fit right in. But it wasn't Paul's event, nor was he there. John admitted several times when referring to that that he was scared stiff. He wasn't aware he had to do a speech and so he was definitely not prepared. John felt bad on his misstep that he overstayed the time by signing his book. Cynthia also signed some books that day.

Mingling with Celebrities

 Cynthia, Victor Spinetti, and John. Victor was John's co-star on A Hard Day's Night, as well as in Help! (1965), Magical Mystery Tour (1967), and appeared in the play adaption of In His Own Write in 1968.
Photographed by Terence Spencer

 Cynthia and Marty Wilde

Cynthia and John sitting apart during lunch at the Dorchester Hotel; Cynthia was sitting next to Wifred Bramwell (Paul's grandfather in A Hard Day's Night) on her right, Marty Wilde, Harry Secombe, an unidentified male, and Lionel Bart in between Cynthia and John.
Photographed by Terence Spencer

Solo Event with Wife